-
Re: It Started Off
Cabassi is right in line with me on this one. You crossed into characters and thus need their emotions, it is becoming more and more like fiction in that aspect, ...
Mar 29, 2008 -
Re: Fiend Kingdom: Darkness Stirring
The whole battle scene was well...not exactly good. Though your use of Phyrexia was funny, but Magic the Gathering holds much to be desired in terms of fighting alone. Even ...
Mar 29, 2008 -
Re: Left Out
I'm not exactly sure what separates this from dramatic poetry, but whatever. The work seems to be one of lost love, not unrequited, but more like immature love. It is ...
Mar 29, 2008 -
Re: Alone and Solo
Some parts don't make too clear of sense, The gutter shot and grave part just seems like some drunken rambling. The shoulders and coffin part as well. And the day ...
Mar 29, 2008 -
Re: Randi
Penguinattack got the corrections. This poem hits home and so does the simple message which all of us can relate to. It is nicely done, rather then going into details ...
Mar 29, 2008 -
Re: But You Can't See In
A bit too unstructured, it went for the 'deep' approach, but came off a little sidetracked and too long to keep the initial awe when you break the form and ...
Mar 29, 2008 -
Re: Painting Sonata
Complex and beautiful. Some of the metaphors need a bit of touching up. 'Waterfall of blushing cheeks' being one. The whole 'in and out' thing after Popsicle fingers doesn't seem ...
Mar 29, 2008 -
Re: You never understand
I must disagree with Niteowl on this one. A poem is not a short story and doesn't have to tell about someone and why. Lament alone is the subject, you ...
Mar 29, 2008 -
Re: Who Do you want to be?
A moral message yes, but this seems to be prose rather then poetry. Using a quote is also in support of the prose judgment for me as well. Just because ...
Mar 29, 2008 -
Re: Ocean
I would lose the seagull descriptions and maybe use a reference to their annoying 'MINE' calls. Though that's just me. The first part of the poem is plain and simple, ...
Mar 29, 2008 -
Re: Friends
I'm going to have to go with the previous two posters on here, but add my own segment in. Word Choice. One of the cornerstones of poetry is using the ...
Mar 29, 2008 -
Re: Diary of a Villain: Prologue Part 1
This was good, some things about the whole soul and weird method of judgment makes Esten seem like a new trainee at the DMV, knowing too much about the procedures, ...
Mar 28, 2008 -
Re: Campfire
Wow this is good, some of the references made like 'dung-beetle' didn't go too well after typical ones like 'vultures'. I think it was 'little fly' that actually made me ...
Mar 28, 2008 -
Re: Irony's Sublimity: The Philine Quartet
Though that was the old style, description and elegance superseded practical flow. If you are going to appreciate the old style then you need to be well-versed in many subjects ...
Mar 28, 2008 -
Re: Trails of Guardian
As I was reading it wasn't exactly captivating, there is little substance and soul to the character, the way you write is very passive and does not grab a hold ...
Mar 28, 2008
